Connection Between B12 Deficiency and Gluten Sensitivity?
B12 Deficiency and gluten sensitivity (GS) are generally considered to be unrelated, except in cases of diagnosed celiac disease (CD). Taking a look at new findings on GS and connecting the dots challenges this assumption. Examining the issue in depth leads us to consider the possibility that vitamin b12 deficiency may be a factor for some GS sufferers as well.
The Numbers On GS May Be higher
First off the numbers on the percentage of the general population suffering from GS may well be higher than originally thought. Estimates are largely speculative and controversial, varying greatly from as little as 1% to as high as 30%.(1)
That’s a huge difference, largely because of the lack of formal research that has gone into exploring this topic. It’s worth looking at this information in the context that:
- Estimates in the higher end of the range come from physician’s on the ground dealing with patients.
- Estimates on the lower end of the scale are generally those put forward by public health authorities.
- The discrepancy likely owes to the fact that many of the official numbers on the bottom of the scale are based on old research dealing strictly with diagnosed celiac disease .
Gluten Sensitivity – A Condition On The Fringe
In many regions of the world disorders involving gluten are not recognized as a priority at the public health administration level.(2) (3) Even here in our developed first world western context there is very little peer reviewed research done on gluten sensitivity even though it is a patient reported problem for a significant percentage of the population. Whatever the final number ends up being it’s likely a larger issue than most people realize. This is probably because gluten sensitivity is not yet regarded as a medical condition in many areas and consequently is under the radar of many health officials. One prominent researcher on the topic Dr. Alessio Fassano, Chief of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition at Massachusetts General Hospital, has been at the forefront of putting GS on the map as a recognized medical condition. His work states that the evidence for GS as health issue separate from CD is definitive and rising in prevalence. By his own admission much more research is required to properly understand the condition and it’s implication for public health. (4)
Where research is being done the numbers on patient reported gluten intolerance deviate on the upside from the commonly accepted lower end of the range of under 1%.
Some Data On Current Research In Western Nations:
Gluten Sensitive Or Early Celiac?
Enter metabonomics, the scientific exploration and analysis of the chemical signatures of cellular metabolism.(7)
Research on metabonomics shows us that some patients reporting GS have metabolic profiles comparable to diagnosed celiacs, with a number of subjects showing injury to the small intestine. As we already know it’s damage to the small intestine ( vis a vis an immunological response to gluten) which can cause absorption issues and consequently chronic nutrient deficiencies.(8)
This biologically based evidence is increasing speculation that many who report being gluten sensitive are potentially early celiac. Prior to this finding the term early celiac didn’t exist. While early celiac is not regarded as a condition, it is now on the radar – a positive development for sufferers who may not be having their concerns addressed by the health system.(1)
If evidence continues to build that a statistically relevant number of GS sufferers are in fact experiencing early CD then it will indeed be a cause for concern. Untreated Celiac disease is a significant health risk. A 2009 study of US Air Force personnel found that individuals with undiagnosed CD had four times the mortality rate than those without the disease. What percentage of these people might have displayed early stage signs of the disease and what relevance this would have had to extending longevity is of course unknown but it’s thought provoking nonetheless.(9)
Potential B12 Deficiency In Early Celiac Disease?
The takeaway from all this is that if some early celiac sufferers are presenting signs of intestinal harm then it is likely nutrient absorption will become an issue if the condition progresses to celiac disease. For instance, vitamin B12 deficiency is recognized as a factor in celiac disease. One Swiss study found that:
- over 80% of freshly diagnosed Celiac sufferers were running a nutrient deficiency
- B vitamins scored high on the list (10)
As outlined above the medical communities understanding of gluten sensitivity is continuing to develop. It’s possible that the number of potential celiac sufferers is underestimated, due to a lack of awareness and data on the existence of early stage CD. If this is in fact the case then it’s possible that a number of those experiencing gluten sensitivity are actually celiac. Providing that this hypothesis proves out with further research, many of these individuals are potentially at risk of becoming vitamin B12 deficient. The established research to date firmly supports the assertion that those with CD are susceptible to being vitamin B12 deficient.
No one knows yet how closely correlated vitamin B12 deficiency and gluten sensitivity are. Given recent findings, logic would hold that it’s currently under represented in the available literature. It would seem that Vitamin B12 deficiency and gluten sensitivity are not mutually exclusive.
Signs Of Gluten Sensitivity
In case this is new territory for you, the following are symptoms of gluten sensitivity:
- digestive issues
- upset stomach
- inability to think clearly
- discomfort in the joints
- lack of energy
- lack of sensation in the limbs and appendages
- dermatological issues such as rashes etc (11)
As with many conditions stemming from immunological responses, symptoms may be broad and varied. Symptoms may also manifest in a highly individual manner.(12)
What To Do If You Suspect You Have Gluten Sensitivity
If you feel that severe gluten sensitivity, and by extension vitamin B12 deficiency, is potentially an issue for you then there is plenty you can do about it. Radically adjusting your diet or rushing out to dose yourself up on nutrients is probably not the best call at the beginning. Instead
- Request a test for celiac disease (Given the lack of awareness on gluten sensitivity as a medical condition in it’s own right starting from the basis of celiac disease might be a good idea if you are trying to get tests from a public health authority etc.)
- If your tTG-IgA blood screen for celiac disease comes up clear (as mine did) and you still suspect that you may have absorption issues then there’s more you can do – an endoscopy ( a quick, low risk, out-patient procedure) can tell you if you are in the clear by analyzing the villi of the small intestine
Once you have all the facts relating to gluten sensitivity and vitamin B12 deficiency you can make an informed decision on how best to proceed. The good news is that early screening for nutrient deficiencies generally can not only tell us what supplements we may need, but what the underlying causes are.
- How Many People Have Gluten Sensitivity?
- Prevalence of Self-Reported Gluten-Related Disorders and Adherence to a Gluten-Free Diet in Salvadoran Adult Population
- Prevalence of Self-Reported Gluten Sensitivity and Adherence to a Gluten-Free Diet in Argentinian Adult Population
- Nonceliac gluten sensitivity
- Prevalence and Characterization of Self-Reported Gluten Sensitivity in The Netherlands
- A UK study assessing the population prevalence of self-reported gluten sensitivity and referral characteristics to secondary care
- A Metabolomic Perspective on Coeliac Diseasehttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3934717/
- Are Patients with Potential Celiac Disease Really Potential? The Answer of Metabonomics
- Increased Prevalence and Mortality in Undiagnosed Celiac Disease
- Vitamin and Mineral Deficiencies Are Highly Prevalent in Newly Diagnosed Celiac Disease Patients
- SYMPTOMS OF NON-CELIAC GLUTEN SENSITIVITY
- 9 gluten-intolerance symptoms you should never ignore